Skip to:

Trainer Comparison

Statistics by Year:
Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 5 14 2.8 0 1 4 0% 35.71% $10,879 $777 $2,176 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 26 157 6.04 20 21 15 12.74% 35.67% $941,350 $5,996 $36,206 1 2

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 6 33 5.5 2 3 7 6.06% 36.36% $42,703 $1,294 $7,117 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 39 187 4.79 13 26 29 6.95% 36.36% $902,693 $4,827 $23,146 1 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 3 8 2.67 0 0 0 0% 0% $3,585 $448 $1,195 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 33 156 4.73 20 17 11 12.82% 30.77% $857,666 $5,498 $25,990 0 2

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 16 80 5 3 3 8 3.75% 17.5% $43,356 $542 $2,710 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 33 136 4.12 14 12 18 10.29% 32.35% $508,859 $3,742 $15,420 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 8 42 5.25 7 3 5 16.67% 35.71% $79,938 $1,903 $9,992 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 33 162 4.91 17 15 23 10.49% 33.95% $607,177 $3,748 $18,399 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 14 75 5.36 14 11 7 18.67% 42.67% $102,019 $1,360 $7,287 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 32 179 5.59 15 19 22 8.38% 31.28% $623,476 $3,483 $19,484 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 16 83 5.19 8 13 9 9.64% 36.14% $88,985 $1,072 $5,562 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 29 170 5.86 19 20 21 11.18% 35.29% $741,781 $4,363 $25,579 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 30 156 5.2 23 21 26 14.74% 44.87% $171,296 $1,098 $5,710 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 33 161 4.88 17 27 15 10.56% 36.65% $626,362 $3,890 $18,981 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 7 10 1.43 2 0 2 20% 40% $10,034 $1,003 $1,433 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 35 161 4.6 24 30 27 14.91% 50.31% $960,841 $5,968 $27,453 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 32 150 4.69 25 18 16 16.67% 39.33% $1,013,315 $6,755 $31,666 0 3

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 7 33 4.71 4 1 4 12.12% 27.27% $36,716 $1,113 $5,245 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 32 149 4.66 23 18 12 15.44% 35.57% $1,069,975 $7,181 $33,437 1 3

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 9 35 3.89 6 3 5 17.14% 40% $100,544 $2,873 $11,172 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 23 114 4.96 20 19 11 17.54% 43.86% $889,453 $7,802 $38,672 0 3

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 13 59 4.54 6 10 5 10.17% 35.59% $56,667 $960 $4,359 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 29 134 4.62 15 27 15 11.19% 42.54% $960,504 $7,168 $33,121 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 9 36 4 10 4 5 27.78% 52.78% $99,428 $2,762 $11,048 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 29 125 4.31 25 14 11 20% 40% $984,305 $7,874 $33,942 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 9 20 2.22 0 2 4 0% 30% $12,034 $602 $1,337 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 28 137 4.89 9 12 6 6.57% 19.71% $370,923 $2,707 $13,247 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 2 4 2 1 2 0 25% 75% $10,838 $2,710 $5,419 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 25 126 5.04 11 23 11 8.73% 35.71% $344,450 $2,734 $13,778 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 21 107 5.1 6 13 10 5.61% 27.1% $178,107 $1,665 $8,481 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 22 103 4.68 6 16 14 5.83% 34.95% $259,000 $2,515 $11,773 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 15 43 2.87 4 6 2 9.3% 27.91% $35,617 $828 $2,374 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 14 81 5.79 6 14 9 7.41% 35.8% $239,387 $2,955 $17,099 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 32 131 4.09 6 4 19 4.58% 22.14% $247,235 $1,887 $7,726 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 3 6 2 1 2 1 16.67% 66.67% $12,857 $2,143 $4,286 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 35 135 3.86 11 17 17 8.15% 33.33% $690,001 $5,111 $19,714 1 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 35 154 4.4 16 15 22 10.39% 34.42% $710,379 $4,613 $20,297 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 7 23 3.29 1 4 1 4.35% 26.09% $12,997 $565 $1,857 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 25 130 5.2 9 15 13 6.92% 28.46% $451,210 $3,471 $18,048 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 8 18 2.25 2 0 2 11.11% 22.22% $13,930 $774 $1,741 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 35 155 4.43 14 19 22 9.03% 35.48% $597,664 $3,856 $17,076 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 18 63 3.5 6 7 11 9.52% 38.1% $102,135 $1,621 $5,674 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 30 128 4.27 13 13 22 10.16% 37.5% $374,087 $2,923 $12,470 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 17 78 4.59 9 12 13 11.54% 43.59% $312,480 $4,006 $18,381 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 19 90 4.74 8 12 17 8.89% 41.11% $211,308 $2,348 $11,121 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 22 115 5.23 13 16 14 11.3% 37.39% $207,558 $1,805 $9,434 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 2 2 1 0 1 0 0% 50% $744 $372 $372 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 18 101 5.61 12 13 13 11.88% 37.62% $115,212 $1,141 $6,401 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2023 National Trainer Avg. 3.96 13.53% 40.55% $5,237 $20,757
Randy Bayley 19 113 5.95 20 25 12 17.7% 50.44% $167,913 $1,486 $8,838 0 0
Paul M. Buttigieg 6 34 5.67 3 4 4 8.82% 32.35% $46,552 $1,369 $7,759 0 0